top of page

One of the most beautiful moments in Schubert

Everyone knows the famous slow movement from the D959 sonata. But in my perhaps controversial opinion, the most extraordinary aspect of this work is not the brutal meltdown about halfway through. My attention tends to wander to what comes immediately afterwards, perhaps one of the single most profound passages of music ever written:



It's a moment of extraordinary compassion- compassion so unadorned and genuine in its concern that it takes your breath away. Compare this moment from Chopin's fourth ballade, emerging, similarly, from chaos which is made to look materialistically overwrought in comparison.


And of course, as if the initial warmth of the major wasn't moving enough, Schubert takes it to the next level with that minor chord round 5.18, which really seems to capture life in all its weird beauty. I was trying to find words which at least palely reflected the poignance of the moment, and a line of Tennyson stirred in my memory, written in memory of a dear friend:


'But thou art turn'd to something strange,

And I have lost the links that bound

Thy changes; here upon the ground,

No more partaker of thy change.'

 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Tribute: Sir Tom Stoppard

Deeply saddened to hear of the death of Sir Tom Stoppard, author of that dazzling, joyous, heartbreaking cocktail of wit and wisdom, Arcadia .* It changed my life when I first read it as a teenager, a

 
 
 
On magical horsemen

I was reading Pedro Calderón de la Barca's play The Surgeon of His Honour, and came across a magnificent description of a horseman seen from afar, given by the rider's former lover (who has not yet re

 
 
 

Comments


©2023 by Shrinidhi Prakash

bottom of page